A two-year study found that when it comes to weight loss, water is no better than diet soda. This completely undercuts the idea that non-sugar sweetened beverages, despite having zero calories, inhibit weight-loss via caloric deficit.
Researchers followed 493 adults with overweight or obesity who were enrolled in a structured behavioral weight-management program. They were assigned to drink either water or commercially available diet drinks daily and were tracked for 104 weeks.
The diet-drink group lost an average of 10.6 pounds (4.8 kilograms), while the water group lost 8.2 pounds (3.7 kilograms). The difference was not statistically significant, and both groups kept the weight off through the second year, including the period after program support ended.
Both groups also saw reductions in waist and hip measurements, improvements in body composition, and improvements in several metabolic-health measures. Blood pressure and cholesterol outcomes showed no clinically meaningful difference between the two groups.
This feels like a good place to quote Dante here:
“What are you removing, and what are you replacing it with?”
That question matters more than whether a drink has a perfect reputation. If someone swaps a daily 20-ounce regular soda for water, that is a great move. But swapping that same sugar-filled beverage for sweet tea, juice, or another sugary drink becuase it's "not soda", isn't going to improve that person's metabolic health. In those cases, a diet soda is a more realistic and effective first step.
The study found no evidence that low- or no-calorie sweeteners disrupted appetite regulation or caused metabolic harm under the conditions studied. Participants consumed aspartame, acesulfame-K, and sucralose at levels within established European safety thresholds.
For someone who drinks soda every day, going straight to plain water can feel like losing a ritual. Diet soda preserves the cold, fizzy, sweet experience while removing most of the sugar and calories.
That can be a practical bridge, not a permanent destination.
A frequent soda drinker might move from regular cola to diet cola, then gradually add sparkling water, unsweetened tea, or plain water into the rotation. Juice and sweet tea may sound more “natural,” but they still deliver a substantial sugar load.
To be clear, water remains the simplest, cheapest, and best choice. That’s not up for debate. The study simply suggests that diet drinks may be a reasonable substitute for sugary drinks when water feels like too big a leap.
The findings also came within a broader behavioral weight-management program, so the drinks were not working alone. Participants also made other changes to eating and activity habits.
The main takeaway here is simple: When it comes to changing habits and behavior, the most useful swap is the one you can actually maintain. Water is the gold standard, but diet soda is a legitimate stepping stone for people who need a gentler transition away from regular soda.
So, ask yourself the question again.
What are you removing, and what are you replacing it with? If the answer is “sugary soda” and “a drink with little or no sugar,” that may be progress worth keeping on your way to reaching the gold standard.
Sources:
https://scitechdaily.com/scientists-tested-diet-drinks-for-2-years-the-results-may-surprise-you/
https://biologyinsights.com/why-water-is-better-for-you-than-soda/
https://www.healthline.com/health/food-nutrition/why-is-water-important